Middle classes fiddle insurance claims

Although many of us are led to believe that fraudulent activities are usually conducted by those from lower income families, a recent report has suggested that many illegal activities in this field are actually committed by middle classes, particularly fraud such as inflated insurance claims.

The results from the survey suggested that a high number of middle class policyholders inflated insurance claims in order to improve their homes or simply to get back at the insurance companies for having to pay high premiums.

The survey was conducting using nearly 2000 respondents from across England and Wales. The report was compiled by Professor Susanne Karstedt and Dr Stephen Farrall of Keele University. Although other types of ‘white collar crime’ were also highlighted in the report, one of the significant types of crime that middle classes admitted to was fiddling insurance claims.

One official stated: ‘Politicians from across the political spectrum regularly claim that most crime is committed by a hard core of offenders, largely drawn from low-income groups. This research demonstrates that volume crime is far more widespread, with the middle class being responsible for a wide range of illegal activities. The reasons for this are complex, and relate to the fundamental social changes in British society over the past 30 years.’

One professor involved with the study added: ‘Contempt for the law is as widespread in the centre of society as it is assumed to be rampant at the margins and among specific marginal groups. Anti-social behaviour by the few is mirrored by anti-civil behaviour by the many. Neither greed nor need can explain why respectable citizens cheat on insurance claims or in second-hand sales, and do not hesitate to discuss their exploits with friends in pubs.’

Tom Smith
15th July 2007